Serge Gnabry – true talent or another of Wenger’s follies?

GnabryLess sexy than Messi and less dramatic than Sanchez: the present references to Serge Gnabry remind us about Wenger’s commitment to give players a chance. There are different views among Arsenal followers about his track record… Some point to Cygan, Senderos, Denilson and Bendtner as examples of excess faith – Wenger , it is argued, gave poor players too much time and should have parted company with them earlier in their careers at AFC. Others point to Song, Coquelin and Flamini as evidence that Wenger is prepared to wait and see if there is scope for development. Some you win and some you lose.

As regards the failure, there is an argument that the longer list of failures – add Arshavin and Silvestre and Jeffries – occurred when Arsenal was a selling club, when Toure, Cesc, RVP, Nasri and Clichy (Adebayor “ugh” as well) were sold to make good the financial costs of the Emirates. Others will say that I am wrong and that I am looking for excuses and that Wenger is over-rated and the period of failure represents his shortcomings and not his proclaimed strengths. You pay your money. You make your choice.

As an undoubted Wenger fan I have to admit to some awkwardness on this topic – the list of failed players is quite long. Was his judgment at fault? Is he more fallible than I am prepared to accept? We all have to be honest and address weaknesses in what we believe. No heads in the sand!

An incredible selection of authentic Arsenal shirts at amazing prices!

An incredible selection of authentic Arsenal shirts at amazing prices!

So now to Gnabry who has had a bad time at WBA. Rather than accept that Gnabry may be another of the failed talents Wenger is prepared to give him a further chance and is arranging a loan move to Brighton. A couple of years ago with Theo and the Ox suffering injuries we saw quite a bit of Gnabry and to my untutored eye he looked exciting. I tweeted this morning about his pass to Cazorla in the 2-0 win against THFC at the Emirates. Cazorla took his goal well but the pass was perfect as Gnabry came inside and sent a diagonal pass to Cazorla. And Gnabry was buzzing in the no 7 position.

In life there are late developers in all walks of life. We see it all around us – in sportsman, children, business. People come to the fore in response to different pressures and challenges. Look how Ozil has changed and revealed a steely determination that we concluded was absent when he missed that penalty against Bayern. There is always risk in staying with young footballers. Some at a low ebb slip away and the book is closed. Others reach the bottom of the barrel and find they have resources to bounce back.


Maybe Gnabry will be one to bounce back. But the whole issue pinpoints the decisions that coaches have to make about quite young footballers who may be sidetracked by fame and money. Hasn’t Wilshere had to come through the same challenge? Food for thought as we track Gnabry’s progress at Brighton.

, , , , , , ,

2 Responses to Serge Gnabry – true talent or another of Wenger’s follies?

  1. A January 7, 2016 at 6:43 pm #

    Interesting read.

    The issue with gnabry is we all know there is talent there and it is capable of playing in the first team as we saw two years back ( time has flown!) And wouldn’t be out of his depth.

    I firmly believe if he hadn’t got injured wenger would have never bought welbeck.

    Personally I think maybe staying at the Emirates would be better so he feels at home again.but at the start of the season I was expecting this year to be when chamberlain became consistent ! So maybe a loan is better.

    He wasn’t a West brom type of player – due to the fact if they got into the lower half of the league, pulis would rely on a different type of football not suited to gnabry. It was his assistant who recommended him due to seeing his performances at youth level.

    Very talented player and I want him to come through at arsenal

  2. Victor Thompson January 8, 2016 at 2:21 pm #

    Very thoughtful article Graham.

    I too thought that Gnabry was an exciting talent and one for the future.

    I understand that he was already injured when he went to W. Brom but I would not have thought that Pulis was the right manager for him. I hope he has not been damaged by the experience. If Wenger has one talent it is how he handles young players and hopefully he will put his arm around this young man. I think Arteta could be invaluable in encouraging a player like him. It would be a shame to see the exhuberance Gnabry first displayed be extinguished.

    Victor Thompson

Leave a Reply